Canyons Criminal Defense Lawyers

Utah Criminal Defense Attorneys

Main Criminal Defense Navigation

  • Canyons Home
  • Defense Strategy
  • How We Can Help
    • Felony Defense
    • Misdemeanors
    • Jury Trials
    • Appeals
    • District Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • 402 Reductions
    • Pardon
    • Expungements
  • Your Defense Team
  • Contact Information

Criminal Defense Firm in Utah

Criminal Defense Attorneys
Serving Clients Statewide

Criminal Defense Law for Mobile Header

  • Criminal Defense
  • Contact Information
Home » Constitutional Rights » Presumption of Innocence – Do We Still Believe?

Presumption of Innocence – Do We Still Believe?

December 9, 2021 By Stephen Howard

“This is going to continue to clog our criminal justice system and retraumatize victims.”  – Salt Lake District Attorney Sim Gill, as quoted by KSL in an article published Nov. 16, 2021.



The KSL article looks at HB 227, which was passed by the Utah Legislature in 2021 to create certain procedural safeguards for a person charged with a violent crime when the available evidence establishes a prima facie case for self defense.

The requirement of a “prima facie” case for self defense means, in essence, that the person charged first has to show that there is evidence to support a belief that they were acting in self defense. If there is sufficient evidence of self defense, then a justification hearing is held at which the prosecutor must present clear evidence that convinces the court that the defendant was not acting in self defense. The prosecution is not required to meet a “proof beyond a reasonable doubt” standard. But the evidence must be fairly clear if the government intends to force the case to a full jury trial.

If the evidence for self defense does not exist, then the procedural safeguards of the justification hearing are not triggered. The idea that these safeguards serve only to “retraumatize victims” is premised on a presumption that the alleged “victim” is in fact a true victim — in other words, a presumption that the defendant is guilty.

Do we still believe in the Constitutional principle that a person is presumed innocent until proven guilty?

Our Constitution was written by people who believed that it was better to allow a few guilty people to go free than to allow the government to wrongfully convict an innocent person. A free society can survive, and even thrive, when there are guilty people who evade punishment. But the freedoms enjoyed in our society are in real jeopardy if we are willing to turn a blind eye when the government wrongfully convicts an innocent person.

Does our society still accept these ideas? Or have we become so accustomed to the freedoms we have enjoyed for so long that we no longer understand their value?

The safeguards put in place by the Constitution and by the legislature are intended to protect the rights of all people, both the innocent and the guilty. A fair judicial system is vital to ensuring that those protections are implemented and enforced. Our freedom depends on it.

Read the original KSL article here – https://www.ksl.com/article/50284891/its-not-working-ksl-investigates-unintended-consequences-of-new-utah-self-defense-law

Filed Under: Constitutional Rights, Criminal Defense in Utah

Related….

  • Criminal Charges for Choosing Your Child's Therapist?
    Criminal Charges for Choosing Your Child's Therapist?
    Who chooses your child's therapist in Utah if your child is the victim of abuse? As a parent, is it your choice? Or does the government decide? And can your choice to switch therapists be used as evidence that you are committing felony witness tampering? Imagine yourself in the following scenario, as a single parent with full parental rights and full legal custody of your minor child:** **Details presented here have been changed or omitted to protect the innocent and to maintain client confidentiality. Government-Funded Treatment for Your Child You learn that your child has been abused by a family…
  • Initial Stages of a Criminal Case - Police Investigation
    Initial Stages of a Criminal Case - Police Investigation
    Fourth Amendment and Fifth Amendment rights are critical in the investigation phase of a criminal case. Whether you are a witness, "person of interest" or suspect, understanding your rights is important.
  • Entrapment Defense in Utah
    Entrapment Defense in Utah
    An entrapment defense can form an important part of a successful criminal defense strategy in Utah. To understand entrapment, we can use fishing as an analogy. A hook is not part of a fish's normal diet. To get a fish to bite, you have to dress up the hook with bits of feather or hair or thread. Fool the fish and make it think the hook is really food, and you might reel in a big one. Similarly, police might try to use bait or tricks or persuasion to get a person to commit a crime even though that person…

Call a Utah Attorney

Call a Criminal Defense Attorney in Utah


Find Utah Criminal Law Help

Paragraph Spacer

5-Star Reviews for Utah Criminal Defense

5-Star Client Reviews

“The [only] wonderful experience I’ve ever had from representation.”


For the People – For Attorneys

Constitutional Rights of the People

Knowing what you are facing in a Utah criminal prosecution is critical in choosing the right attorney to defend your rights. Articles in this section provide imformation about Utah's criminal justice system that each person should know. Click to learn more.

For Criminal Defense Attorneys in Utah - Information

The "For Attorneys" section provides tips and articles from the Canyons team intended to assist Utah defense attorneys improve their knowledge base and hone the skills needed to successfully represent clients facing criminal prosecution. These materials must be considered in context of relevant constitutional provisions, procedural rules, case law, and statutes. Reliance on these materials by individuals without the assistance of an experienced attorney is not recommended.

Contact Form 7

    Find a Utah Criminal Defense Team






    CONTACT US

    Case Results – Select Victories in Utah Criminal Defense

    Utah Criminal Defense Wins

    Client faced felony charges for allegedly using a gun to menace another driver during road rage incident. Defense trial strategy demonstrated that the alleged victim was the likely aggressor and that client had taken reasonable action to defend himself.

    Father was arrested and held on half-million dollar bail for allegedly kidnapping his own child. Defense counsel demonstrated legal impossibility under the circumstances and prosecutor agreed to dismiss outright.

    Client faced first-degree felony charges for selling drugs to undercover police officer. Mitigating evidence gathered by defense relating to client’s youth, family support, treatment options, and lack of prior history was pivotal in convincing prosecutor to allow an abeyance agreement to a single misdemeanor count. Case was ultimately dismissed.

    Utah CLE Events / Calendar for Criminal Defense Attorneys

    For Utah Lawyers

    Canyons Law Group defense team presents on topics relating to internet crimes, including: prosecutor's constitutional discovery obligations; digital technology issues in discovery; police practices in internet "sting" cases; statutory history and interpretation for defense; and more.
    ↽⇀

    Contact Canyons Law Group directly to register. Space is limited.
    ↽⇀

    One hour MCLE credit for Utah attorneys pending approval.

    • Felonies
    • Misdemeanors
    • District Courts
    • Justice Courts

    Constitutional – Utah Defense Attorneys

    Sixth Amendment Double Jeopardy - Utah Criminal Lawyer

    Constitutional Rights

    P Spacer

    • Team Strategy
    • Jury Trials
    • Appeals
    • Expungements

    Constitutional Rights Legal Education

    Criminal Defense Attorneys Utah - Constitutional Rights

    Fifth Amendment Miranda RIghts


    Search for Utah Criminal Law Information

    Contact Information for Utah Criminal Defense Lawyers

    Canyons Law Group, LLC
    Offices in Salt Lake and Davis Counties
    Serving Clients Statewide

    952 South Main St., Suite A
    Layton, UT 84041

    560 South 300 East, Suite 200
    Salt Lake City, UT 84111

    801-449-1409

    Utah Criminal Defense Locations

    Serving Northern Utah and the Wasatch Front
    Salt Lake, Davis, Weber, Cache, Tooele, Summit, Box Elder, Morgan, and Wasatch Counties

    Serving Central and Southern Utah
    Washington, Iron, Kane, Sevier, Sanpete, Juab, and Carbon Counties

    Make Online Payment

    Payments for Utah Attorneys
    • EnglishEnglish
    • EspañolEspañol
    Criminal Defense Page Archve
    Sitemap

    Copyright © 2010–2023 · Canyons Law Group, LLC · Stephen W. Howard, PC

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.