Stephen Howard - Criminal Defense Attorney

Mr. Howard will soon be joining Stone River Law.

Main Criminal Defense Navigation

  • Canyons Home
  • Defense Strategy
  • How We Can Help
    • Felony Defense
    • Misdemeanors
    • Jury Trials
    • Appeals
    • District Courts
    • Justice Courts
    • 402 Reductions
    • Pardon
    • Expungements
  • Your Defense Team
  • Contact Information

Criminal Defense Firm in Utah

Criminal Defense Attorneys
Serving Clients Statewide

Criminal Defense Law for Mobile Header

  • Criminal Defense
  • Contact Information
Home » Criminal Defense Attorneys Utah » Expungement Hearings in Utah – Yes and No

Expungement Hearings in Utah – Yes and No

August 19, 2020 By Stephen Howard


Are courts in Utah required to hold a hearing on an expungement petition? Utah law provides both a clear “yes” and a clear “no” answer to this question.

Unopposed Expungement Petitions

Under the Utah Expungement Act, Utah Code section 77-40-107, a court can grant a petition to expunge criminal records without holding a hearing on the petition if no objection is filed and received by the court within 60 days of the date the original petition is filed. The court may also grant a petition to expunge without a hearing if the prosecutor has agreed, stipulated, or otherwise affirmatively waived the right to object to the expungement.

Objections to the Petition

Before any expungement can be granted, the Utah Expungement Act requires that the prosecution and any victim be given an opportunity to respond to the petition. Even if a prosecutor does not oppose the expungement, a victim can file an independent objection. In some cases, the Department of Corrections Division of Adult Probation and Parole may also provide input to the court.

Subsection (6)(a) of Utah Code 77-40-107 states that if the court receives an objection to the petition “from any party, the court shall set a date for a hearing and notify the petitioner….”

The word “shall” is generally interpreted by courts as creating a mandatory obligation. Therefore, if an objection is filed, the court is required to set a hearing on the expungement petition.

Following the hearing, the court will make a formal decision either granting or denying the petition. But when a petition to expunge is contested, the court cannot deny the petition without first giving the petitioner the right to be heard in court on the matter.

Constitutional Guarantees

When an expungement petition is filed with the court, there is no guarantee that the court will grant the petition. Utah law establishes a relatively high burden proof for the petitioner, requiring clear and convincing evidence that the requested expungement is not contrary to the public interest.

Although the ultimate result carries no guarantee, Constitutional principles of due process guarantee the individual right to notice and an opportunity to be heard. The hearing requirement established under Utah Code 77-40-107 is consistent with these constitutional protections.

Practical Application

Under ideal circumstances, a prosecutor may read the initial expungement petition and immediately agree that the petitioner’s criminal record should be expunged. When circumstances are less than ideal, a prosecutor may object to the expungement petition even when basic statutory eligibility requirements are met.

A well-crafted petition can play a critical role in the expungement process. In addition to basic eligibility requirements, the Utah Expungement Act requires a petitioner to demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence that the requested expungement is not contrary to the public interest. If the written petition is sufficiently persuasive, a prosecutor may stipulate to the expungement without ever requiring that a hearing be held.


Filed Under: Criminal Defense Attorneys Utah

Related….

  • 402 Reduction Process in Utah
    402 Reduction Process in Utah
    A felony conviction can be reduced to a misdemeanor, or a misdemeanor can be reduced to a lower degree by filing a motion under Utah Code section 76-3-402. This process is commonly referred to as a "402 reduction." It can be useful in clearing felony convictions from a criminal history record, in shortening the waiting period required for expungement, and in restoring expungement eligibility. How and when this tool may be used in cleaning up a person's criminal record will depend on several different factors. This page presents only general information on the requirements for obtaining a 402 reduction. For…
  • Entrapment Defense in Utah
    Entrapment Defense in Utah
    An entrapment defense can form an important part of a successful criminal defense strategy in Utah. To understand entrapment, we can use fishing as an analogy. A hook is not part of a fish's normal diet. To get a fish to bite, you have to dress up the hook with bits of feather or hair or thread. Fool the fish and make it think the hook is really food, and you might reel in a big one. Similarly, police might try to use bait or tricks or persuasion to get a person to commit a crime even though that person…
  • Expungement Waiting Times
    Expungement Waiting Times
    Does the waiting period for expungement eligibility in Utah start when the case is closed or when State Debt Collections files a satisfaction of judgment with the court? Utah Code 77-40-105 governs the preliminary requirements for eligibility for expungement of convictions. Payment in full of any restitution or fines (including interest) must be made in order to be eligible for expungement. But payment is not what sets the clock ticking on other eligibility requirements. Waiting periods for expungement eligibility range from three years to ten years, depending on the level of the offense and the type of offense involved. These…

Call a Utah Attorney

Call a Criminal Lawyer in Utah


Find Utah Criminal Law Help

Paragraph Spacer

For the People – For Attorneys

Constitutional Rights of the People

Knowing what you are facing in a Utah criminal prosecution is critical in choosing the right attorney to defend your rights. Articles in this section provide imformation about Utah's criminal justice system that each person should know. Click to learn more.

Important Information for Criminal Defense Lawyers in Utah

The "For Attorneys" section provides tips and articles from the Canyons team intended to assist Utah defense attorneys improve their knowledge base and hone the skills needed to successfully represent clients facing criminal prosecution. These materials must be considered in context of relevant constitutional provisions, procedural rules, case law, and statutes. Reliance on these materials by individuals without the assistance of an experienced attorney is not recommended.

Contact Form 7




    CONTACT US

    Case Results – Select Victories in Utah Criminal Defense

    Utah Criminal Defense Attorney Wins

    Client faced felony charges for allegedly using a gun to menace another driver during road rage incident. Defense trial strategy demonstrated that the alleged victim was the likely aggressor and that client had taken reasonable action to defend himself.

    While represented by a different attorney, client was convicted of DUI by jury at trial. Mr. Howard filed an appeal challenging the district court’s denial of a motion to suppress. Appellate court reversed the trial court and the case was dismissed.

    First-degree felony burglary charges with gang enhancement were filed based on client’s participation in burglary planned by other individuals. Based on client’s peripheral involvement and evidence his conduct was out of character, prosecutor consented to abeyance agreement at misdemeanor level that would ultimately lead to case dismissal.

    • Felonies
    • Misdemeanors
    • District Courts
    • Justice Courts

    Constitutional – Utah Defense Attorneys

    Sixth Amendment Double Jeopardy - Utah Criminal Lawyer

    Constitutional Rights

    P Spacer

    • Team Strategy
    • Jury Trials
    • Appeals
    • Expungements

    Constitutional Rights Legal Education

    Criminal Defense Attorneys Utah - Constitutional Rights

    Fifth Amendment Miranda RIghts


    Search for Utah Criminal Law Information

    Contact Information for Utah Criminal Defense Lawyers

    Canyons Law Group, LLC
    Offices in Salt Lake and Davis Counties
    Serving Clients Statewide

    952 South Main St., Suite A
    Layton, UT 84041

    560 South 300 East, Suite 200
    Salt Lake City, UT 84111

    801-449-1409

    Utah Criminal Defense Locations

    Serving Northern Utah and the Wasatch Front
    Salt Lake, Davis, Weber, Cache, Tooele, Summit, Box Elder, Morgan, and Wasatch Counties

    Serving Central and Southern Utah
    Washington, Iron, Kane, Sevier, Sanpete, Juab, and Carbon Counties

    Make Online Payment

    Payments for Utah Attorneys
    Criminal Defense Page Archve
    Sitemap

    Copyright © 2010–2023 · Canyons Law Group, LLC · Stephen W. Howard, PC

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.