Salt Lake Criminal Defense Attorney Utah
Criminal Defense Attorney Stephen Howard
Call Criminal Defense Attorney in Utah
Call Utah Criminal Lawyer
Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyers / Former Prosecutors
Call 801-449-1409 now to see what our criminal defense team can do for you.
Utah Criminal Defense Lawyer Salt Lake City

Criminal Defense Solutions Start HereSM

Finding a Felony Defense LawyerChoosing a Misdemeanor Defense LawyerDrug and Alcohol Crimes Defense LawyerWhite Collar Defense Attorney for Utah ChargesAttorney for Expungements Reductions and PardonsDefendant Constitutional Rights Criminal LawyerBail and Bond Alternatives in UtahReasons for Hope Facing Criminal Charges

Mental Illness Defense in Utah

Can a mental illness serve as a defense in Utah criminal cases?

It is sometimes assumed (incorrectly) that a mental illness defense can be raised in a Utah criminal prosecution case only when the charged crime is one requiring evidence of "specific intent." Raising a mental illness defense is complicated regardless of the nature of the offense charged. But depending on the nature of the illness and on the circumstances of the alleged defense, a mental illness defense in a felony or misdemeanor case can potentially apply to either a specific intent or general intent crime.

When facing criminal charges, it is vital to have the effective assistance of counsel. Contact us today to see how our criminal defense team can help.

Specific Intent or General Intent

With the exception of so-called "strict liability" crimes, a criminal offense in Utah will require some level of culpable mental state. This required mental state is often referred to by the Latin term "mens rea" (translated roughly as "guilty mind"). Criminal charges can generally be divided into two categories of mens rea based on either a "specific intent" or a "general intent."

Criminal Attorney Salt Lake City, UtahA general intent crime requires only proof that the person generally intended to commit the act. For example, a charge of DUI requires only that the prosecutor prove that the defendant intended to drive the vehicle. The prosecutor does not have to prove that the defendant intended to be drunk or impaired, or even that he was aware of the fact that he was drunk or impaired. If the prosecutor can convince a jury beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant had the general intent to act (sometimes referred to as committing a "willful" act) and that the act satisfied the other elements of the offense, then a jury may convict on a general intent crime.

A specific intent crime differs from a general intent offense by requiring that the defendant act with some specified purpose or intent. For example, In a burglary case a defendant can be convicted if a jury finds that he unlawfully entered a home "with the intent to commit a theft." A general intent only to enter a home unlawfully would constitute the lesser misdemeanor crime of trespass. But if the specific intent to commit a theft is added to the trespass, then a charge of burglary can be supported.

Applying Mental Illness as a Defense

It is commonly accepted by most Utah practitioners that a mental illness defense can apply to specific intent crimes. A general intent crime can present a less straightforward problem. But there is nothing in Utah's mental illness defense statute that restricts the application of the defense only to specific intent crimes.

Further, some crimes that are often thought of as general intent crimes have alternate elements that can turn the offense into a specific intent crime. Consider the crime of assault as an example. Utah's statutes defining the crime of assault generally provide multiple alternative elements by which a charge of assault can be proved.

One alternative set of elements under Utah's assault laws requires evidence that the defendant "attempted" to do bodily injury. A crime that involves an "attempt" will almost always involve an element of specific intent. In an assault case prosecuted under the "attempt" alternative, the prosecutor must present evidence that the defendant had the actual intent or purpose to cause injury.

Another alternative set of elements requires proof that a defendant made a threat that was accompanied by a show of force. The concept of a "threat" has an inherent element of intent. If a person waves a hand in the air to say hello, that is no threat. If someone else sees the friendly wave and mistakenly interprets it as a threat, the person waving still is not making a threat. It is only when the person waves a hand in the air with the intent to intimidate, cause fear, etc. that an actual threat is made.

A third alternative set of elements that can support an assault charge in Utah includes "an act committed with unlawful force or violence" that causes injury. This alternative is often viewed as requiring only general intent, and in some cases that assessment would be correct. But to be certain, the facts surrounding the use of force and the causation of injury would need to be evaluated.

Under basic principles of Newtonian physics, any act that results in an injury must necessarily involve some kind of "force" (as well as a second force which must equal the first force - equal and opposite reaction). But not every use of "force" is unlawful. Often it is the actor's intent that makes a force unlawful. A doctor who accidentally slips with a scalpel might cause a laceration injury to a patient that would be similar to the injury caused by someone who attempts to stab an opponent with a knife during a fight. The severity of the laceration might be different. But it would still be the intent of the actor that would make the difference between "lawful" and "unlawful" use of force.

Defense or Mitigation

Regardless of whether a crime is a general intent offense or a specific intent offense, if a defendant has a mental illness then a possible defense relating to that mental illness should be considered. In some circumstances, the mental illness may serve as the basis for a complete defense to the charge. But even if there is not a complete defense based on the mental illness, case mitigation can often be supported by demonstrating how the mental illness could have contributed to the commission of the crime or how proper treatment of the condition will reduce the risk of recidivism.

Finding a Defense Attorney in Utah

Utah Criminal Defense LawyerAny criminal conviction can carry serious consequences. Whether you are facing felony or misdemeanor charges, having an experienced defense attorney on your side is critical to achieving the results you need.

The right defense strategy and the right criminal defense attorney can make all the difference. Contact us today to see how we can help you.

Best Rating
Make a Payment to Your Account
Get Help Now
Name: Email: Phone: Describe your legal needs here:
I accept the disclaimer below.
Disclaimer: No attorney-client relationship is established by the use of this form. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be submitted through this form. By clicking 'submit' I am only requesting that I be contacted for the purpose of obtaining legal services.

This form protected by reCAPTCHA.

  • Selected Victories
  • Criminal Defense AttorneyDismissed - Contractor was charged with theft by deception for allegedly misusing customer funds and failing to complete work that had been agreed upon. A successful motion to quash on legal grounds following the bindover order at preliminary hearing resulted in a complete dismissal of all charges.
  • Drug Crimes Defense Attorney Utah Dismissed - Client was facing multiple cases involving first-degree felony drug distribution charges for allegedly selling to a confidential informant. Defense analysis of the case revealed fatal flaws in the prosecution case that ultimately resulted in a complete dismissal of all cases and charges.
  • Utah Expungement Attorney Expungement - Worked to restore client's expungement eligibility through 402 reduction process, then filed successful expungement petitions in multiple courts obtaining expungement orders and clearing client's official criminal history.
  • Violent Crimes Assalt Defense UtahDismissed at Preliminary Hearing - Client charged with aggravated robbery and facing life in prison. Full case analysis and consultation with client allowed the development of a strong defense strategy. Effective cross-examination of the alleged victim at the preliminary hearing resulted in an outright dismissal of all charges by the judge.
Best Criminal Defense Strategy

The best outcome is more likely when the right strategy is employed. Developing the best strategy can require real courtroom experience, a thorough understanding of procedural and substantive legal issues, and a determination to ensure that important constitutional and other legal rights are protected. Choosing the right attorney....

Strategy »
Salt Lake Criminal Defense Attorney Profile Utah

Our criminal defense lawyers have represented clients facing some of the most serious felony charges on the books in Utah. Whether you are facing prosecution for felony or misdemeanor charges, you can be assured that our attorneys have the experience, knowledge, and determination necessary to help you achieve the results you need. Choosing the best defense attorney for your case will be one of the most important decisions you make....

Experience »
Conviction Consequences in Utah Criminal Prosecutions

Jail time, prison time, thousands of dollars in fines, and the lifetime collateral consequences of having a criminal conviction on your record - all of these and more are at stake when you are facing criminal prosecution in Utah. Understanding what is at risk is critical. Even so-called "minor" misdemeanor cases can have serious consequences....

Consequences »
Criminal Defense Attorney in Utah - Reasons to Hope

Clients sometimes ask what the "worst case scenario" is for their charges. We prefer to take a more positive approach. Facing criminal prosecution in Utah can have serious consequences. But you can take steps and make choices right now that will improve your chances of a positive outcome. Let us help you....

Reasons to Hope »
Home | Attorney Profile | Case Results | Criminal Code | FAQ | Legal Resources | Defense Strategy | Contact Us

Serving Salt Lake, Davis, Weber, Utah, Cache, Tooele, Summit, Box Elder, and Wasatch Counties, and all of Utah.

Attorney Stephen Howard practices as part of the Canyons Law Group, LLC and Stephen W. Howard, PC.

Offices in Salt Lake and Davis Counties
560 South 300 East, Suite 200, Salt Lake City, UT 84111
952 S. Main St., Suite A, Layton, UT 84041

Call now to arrange for a confidential initial consultation with an experienced and effective Utah criminal defense lawyer.

In Salt Lake City, call 801-449-1409.
In Davis County, call 801-923-4345.

Stephen W. Howard, PC

The materials in this website are intended for informational purposes only, and are not legal advice. Viewing or responding to materials in this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. Read Full Disclaimer.