Davis County Utah

DUI Defense Attorney – Actual Physical Control


Stephen Howard — Attorney at Law

Under Utah DUI laws, a person can be chargedย withย DUIย without actually driving a vehicle. ย Like most DUI statutes, Utahโ€™s DUI statute provides that a person can be convicted for โ€œdrivingโ€ while under the influence. ย But under Utah law, a person can be convicted of DUI even if he or she is only in โ€œactual physical controlโ€ of a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

The Utah Court of Appeals gave the term โ€œactual physical controlโ€ a broad interpretation in the case ofย State v. Barnhart, 850 P.2d 473 (Utah Ct. App. 1993). ย According to the opinion of the Utah Court of Appeals,ย the legislature โ€œintended to prevent intoxicated persons from causing harm by apprehending them before they operate a vehicle.โ€ ย To be in โ€œactual physical control of a vehicle,โ€ the court held that a person โ€œonly needs to have the apparent ability to start and move a vehicle in order to be in actual physical control.โ€ ย According to the Utah Court of Appeals, the a person does not have to actually move the vehicle to be in โ€œactual physical control.โ€

To determine whether a person is in โ€œactual physical controlโ€ of a vehicle, a jury may consider factors including whether the person was awake or asleep when found by police, which seat of the vehicle the person is sitting in, whether the vehicleโ€™s engine was running, whether the person had the keys to the ignition, whether there was anyone else in the vehicle, the vehicleโ€™s position, how the vehicle got to that place, and other factors the jury may deem relevant.

Whether you are actually โ€œdrivingโ€ a vehicle under the influence, or are only in โ€œactual physical control,โ€ the penalties for a conviction can be equally harsh. ย DUI convictions in Utah carry mandatory sentencing provisions, even on aย misdemeanorย level. ย If you have two prior DUIย convictions (or convictions for related charges) within a 10-year period, your third DUI can be charged as aย felony.